If the
musical health of a city is gauged by the number of concerts it hosts, then
Singapore is in robust musical health.
Most days of the week something is happening on the classical music
front, and at weekends the diary can get very crowded indeed. This last weekend was a typical example,
where very difficult choices had to be made about what to attend and what to
miss. There was a big Mahler event
taking place on Saturday, and I imagine most Singapore music-lovers gravitated
towards that.
Not me. I chose to give Mahler a miss and took the
bus up to a remote hill-top monastery in Bukit Batok to hear some Byrd.
The
alliteration certainly attracted my attention.
After all, as regular readers know, for me, alliteration absolutely
always attracts attention – the concept of taking the Bukit Batok Byrd Bus was
linguistically irresistible. But what
really swung my choice in favour of Byrd was that Mahler symphonies are
performed with such frequency in Singapore that I have reached saturation point
– I think I could go to my grave quite happily now without ever hearing another
Mahler symphony. I’ve heard Mahler 2 more times over the last decade in
Singapore than I did in my entire previous existence, and much as I like the
work, a little over-indulgent emotional excess can go a very long way indeed.
I count the
music of William Byrd among my most absolute favourite. I checked my personal record collection just
now, and discovered I had more recordings of Byrd than of any other single
composer. I was probably around five or
six when I first encountered Byrd. Since
then I have sung Byrd, accompanied Byrd and conducted Byrd. When I was in England I reckon I heard Byrd
at least once a week. But in Singapore
Byrd is rare, and when you do catch some, it is always a moment to savour. I hear it from time to time sung liturgically
in the Cathedral of the Good Shepherd, but despite a plethora of choirs in
Singapore, few are either willing or able to tackle Byrd. After all to sing Byrd properly requires a
particular level of intellectual insight and musical wit, and I’m not sure the
current pool of American-trained, soft-core-pop-orientated choral directors
possesses that sort of insight or wit.
Cappella
Martialis is a small group of like-minded enthusiasts who specialise in singing
the kind of sacred and liturgical music which forms the very foundations of
modern choral singing. They may not do
it particularly well technically, but they do it with love and sincerity, and
that, to me, matters far, far more than having every little detail perfectly
manicured. On Saturday more than once things
seemed on the brink of collapse as a voice or two fell by the wayside, as
tuning sagged, balance wobbled dangerously and stability of pitch was a very
rare commodity. (Why do choirs here seem so terrified of pitch pipes? Surely it’s better for the singers to hear
their pitch blown clearly and steadily, than to wait for a single member to pluck
a starting note from a tuning fork thrust against an ear-lobe?) But there was a powerful feeling of
collective involvement in the spirit of the music which easily overwhelmed
these technical flaws.
When I had
last seen Cappella Martialis perform, they had rather spoiled things with a
stage manner which reminded me of nothing other than a flock of sheep in a
field determined to avoid the ministrations of the guiding sheep dog. Things had improved beyond measure for this
performance, and as a stage presentation, it had a good sense of occasion and a
feeling that it had been, at the very least, thought through. There did seem to have been a little pay off
in quality of singing, and the conductor’s single-minded obsession with beating
time and keeping the singers together meant that everything sounded as if it
was being sung by a group of individuals jogging around the athletics track – a
notion reinforced by the very obvious beating time from singers with both hands
firmly affixed to copies.
But if on a
purely technical level the singing lacked polish, and there was a lurking suspicion
that it simply had not been rehearsed thoroughly enough, there was absolute sincerity
and conviction in this singing which transcended everything else in the performance. It had the power to move and inspire; it was
not a pretty sound but it was dazzling in the beauty of vision it conjured up
in the listener.
Perhaps the
most impressive thing here, though, was the obvious amount of deep and thorough
research which had gone into the programme.
Cappella Martialis programme booklets
are a work of art, full of fascinating historical insight, beautiful and
carefully chosen illustrations, and so much information, that they are best
read at leisure (which is why, I assume, they send out the programme booklets
in advance to the audience). They are
also privileged to have among their number a fine scholar who delivers
fascinating, enlightening and intriguing insights to set the music in context before
each part of the concert. Among the gems
he offered up on Saturday night was the thought that we were hearing music
which was not just written as an act of rebellion, but as one of treason. He drew our attention to little coded
messages and signs in the music; and I have to confess to having become so
familiar with these works that I had never stopped to think much about either
their context or these coded signs. When
the choir sang the word “Catholic” in the Credo
from the Mass for Four Voices,
suddenly moving into chordal harmony and repeating the word, the incredible
bravery and political risk Byrd was taking was revealed in all its amazing
glory.
Here was a
concert which conclusively showed that, if the music is good enough, we do not
need a polished, technically flawless performance to convey its meaning. All we need are people who both understand
and love what it is all about, and we certainly had those on this occasion. My decision to give Mahler the Byrd on Saturday
was thoroughly vindicated.
Hi, thanks a lot for this information. I loves to read this blog. Keep it up
ReplyDeleteBy the way, visit the new post at my blog Best books for iit jee preparation to get free ebooks in reference of academic engineering field and highly competitive engineering exams.
Fantastic. Yash Rawat, I was browsing this classical music blog in the hope of finding out about engineering text books and exams, and so I am delighted to find this information. You don't by any chance have information of insurance, and how to claim on car accident injuries also ?
DeleteHow many times have you heard Mahler 2 in the past decade in Singapore?
ReplyDeleteAbout fifteen.
ReplyDeleteWhich groups played the symphony and when?
DeleteCBSO, under Simon Rattle, in the comfort of my living room, with a nice glass of red wine. Usually on a Friday evening. Not to be missed.
ReplyDeleteI don't usually allow anonymous comments, but these were all too entertaining to delete!
ReplyDelete